Misc. thoughts from someone who was fairly into Trek (gave up at some point with Voyager, though I did see the last couple of episodes, including the finale… only saw the pilot of Enterprise [worst opening credit music ever btw]), but is perfectly ok with the series getting a reboot:
- While I enjoyed the movie, there are a bunch of things that don’t hold up under closer scrutiny, without getting too specific:
- Nero’s ship is awfully powerful for a mining ship (this is explained in the comic book, but most people won’t read that),
- Interesting way to deal with a mutineer.. (I heard starships have brigs)
- Regarding said mutineer and where he landed, chance should never favor the protagonist… really sloppy writing there.
- Then of course there’s Nero’s whole “mission”… (spoilers follow, highlight to read…) I would think that given an opportunity to go back in time, the chance to save your planet would be more important than taking -vengeance, especially since he has all the tools necessary to do it…
- This is a little bit spoiler-ish, but presumably, RIP Sybok and Tuvok…
- I found BSG‘s influence on the movie rather interesting, shaky-cam CGI, switching phasers from beam weapons to projectiles, and more or less dispensing with shields entirely (Did anyone see a shield actually deflect something in the movie? I didn’t.)
- The Cloverfield cameo was kind of unnecessary, I think.
- I question whether in the quest to reboot the franchise, Abrams & Co. have forgotten what makes Trek unique. Take away the fan service in terms of the characterization and focus on the plot…. Is it Trek? I don’t think so… This doesn’t mean it needs to be inaccessible “high concept” SF (though I personally would be ok with that), but I’m hoping future Trek movies get back to some sort of vision (Roddenberry’s or otherwise) vs. big explosions..
- While I agree that the franchise did indeed need a reboot, it’s not like they haven’t tried to make the franchise more mass market friendly in the past…
Feel free to chip in with your $0.02 either on darklight.org or on Facebook…